You have decades of evidence that you have always been like this. An essay on the difference between a groove worn by repetition and the person who was walking.
What you have always done is not who you have always been.
The 35 Chains, The Past, essay 5 of 5. The whole series.
“I have always been like this.”
You say it with a shrug, or a laugh, or the flat tone of a person reading a weather report. And the people who love you nod because they have seen it too. Always the one who runs late. Always the one who cannot say no. Always anxious, always the quiet one, always the one who blows up and then apologizes, always the one who leaves the party first without saying goodbye. The evidence is overwhelming. You have thirty or forty or sixty years of it, a consistent record, and at some point the record stopped being a description of what you do and became the definition of what you are, and now when you imagine being different, it feels less like a change and more like a lie, like pretending to be someone you are not.
I want to hold that sentence up to the light, the one about having always been this way, because it is said with total conviction more often than it is true, and finding out it is not true tends to be one of the quiet turning points of a life.
Here is what I want you to try. Think of something you do every day without deciding to, the route you drive to work, the way you make coffee, the side of the bed you sleep on. You have done it a thousand times. Nobody would say the route to work is who you are. It is a groove worn by repetition, and if the road closed tomorrow you would find another one and be no less yourself. Now take the thing you say you have always been, the anxiety or the withdrawing or the temper, and look at it with the same eyes. It is also a groove. It was worn in early, probably, and deepened by use, and it has become so smooth that you slide into it before you notice you are moving, and the sliding feels like being yourself because it is effortless, and you have confused effortless with true.
But a groove is a groove. It records where you have gone. It does not say who was walking.
A man once said, in the first minutes of a first conversation, that he had always been a coward. That was his word. He had a lifetime of evidence, moments he backed down, things he never said, and he laid them out like a prosecutor. And then, asked directly, he told the story of the day his brother was drowning in a river when they were boys, and how he went in without thinking, and got him, and nearly did not make it back. He had never once counted that. It did not fit the record, so it had been filed under exception. Asked which one was the habit and which one was the man, he had no answer, and something loosened in his face that had been tight for fifty years.
A groove records where you have gone. It does not say who was walking.
Every long running pattern is, at bottom, a performance that started for a reason. The quiet one learned early that quiet was safe. The one who cannot say no learned that yes kept the peace. The one who blows up learned that volume was the only thing that got heard in a loud house. These were adaptations, and good ones, clever solutions arrived at by a child with limited options, and they worked, which is why they lasted. But a solution that lasts long enough starts to look like a personality, and a personality that has been in place long enough starts to feel like a soul, and somewhere in that drift the person who came up with the solution gets forgotten, buried under the very thing they invented to survive.
That person is not gone. That is the whole point. The child who chose quiet could also choose to speak. The choosing was the real self, and it is still here. What you call your nature is a very old decision, made under pressure, that nobody ever revisited. Try, almost as an experiment, doing a few small things against the grain of what you have always done, and the strangest part is how little resistance there is underneath. The resistance is all in the anticipation. Once the new thing is done, it tends to feel, if anything, more like the self doing it than the old thing had, as though a coat had been worn so long it was forgotten it could come off, and underneath it the skin was still there and still warm.
I want to describe what it is like to separate the performance from the person, because you might expect it to feel like losing yourself, and it feels like the opposite.
First there is a period of unfamiliarity. You do a thing you have never done, you say no, or you stay at the party, or you let a silence sit instead of filling it, and there is a moment of vertigo, because the groove is not under your feet and you are on open ground. That moment passes faster than you think. And what replaces it is a kind of recognition. Oh, you think. This is what it feels like to decide. You did not know how much of your life had been sliding, and now, on the open ground, every step is yours, and there is a lightness to that which the groove never had, since sliding, for all its ease, was never chosen.
Then the people around you begin to notice, and this is where it gets interesting, because some of them are relieved, and a few of them are uneasy, since they had built their own routines around your groove and now the ground has shifted under them too. Let them adjust. What you are showing them is that the record was never the person, and some of them will take it as permission to look at their own.
And finally there is the quiet. When you stop maintaining a pattern, you find out how much of your energy was going into it. The one who has always been anxious is working very hard, all day, at being anxious, even if it feels like the anxiety is happening to her. When the performance is set down, the energy comes home, and people describe a stillness they had never had access to, a sense of being simply present, in the room, as themselves, without a script running underneath.
You have always done this. The one who was doing it is older than the habit, and calmer than the habit, and is still, after all these years, capable of surprising you. Go and do one small thing against the grain this week and see who shows up. I think you will know them.
If I have always been this way, is that not just who I am?
A long record of a behavior proves that you have done it repeatedly. It does not prove that the behavior is your identity. Repetition wears a groove, and sliding into a groove feels natural because it is effortless, but effortless and true are different things. The person who first chose the behavior, usually as a child under pressure, is still present and can choose differently.
How can I tell the difference between my personality and a long running habit?
Look for the exceptions. Almost everyone has moments that do not fit their record, the coward who went into the river, the quiet one who spoke up when it mattered. Those moments are usually filed away as flukes. Take them seriously instead. They are evidence of who was walking before the groove was worn.
Why does changing a lifelong pattern feel like lying or pretending?
Because the pattern is so familiar that anything else feels like a costume. The reverse is closer to the truth. The pattern was the costume, put on early for good reasons, and worn so long it began to feel like skin. When people do a small thing against the grain, the most common report is that the new thing felt more like them than the old one.
What do I do about the people who expect me to stay the same?
Let them adjust. Some will be relieved and some will be uneasy, because they built their own routines around your pattern. That is their work, and most of them will do it. A few will take your change as permission to look at their own.
What does it feel like once the pattern is set down?
Unfamiliar at first, then like recognition. People describe the moment of vertigo passing quickly and being replaced by a sense of deciding rather than sliding. The energy that went into maintaining the pattern comes back, and with it a stillness and presence that the groove never offered.
The 35 Chains, The Past, essay 5 of 5. The whole series lives at jamestippins.com/35chains. The thirty-five statements it grew from, and the thirty-five that answer them, are at autonomycommission.com/chains. Many who read them find one that is theirs.
Part of The 35 Chains, essay 5 of 35. Next: The Weather and the Ground.
If this named something
you have been carrying —
That recognition is where the work starts. A discovery call is one focused conversation: no pitch, no commitment. You leave knowing what is actually going on and whether working together makes sense.
Book a Discovery Call